Effort is under assault, and I'm not here for it
Convenience is the promise of every tool the now ubiquitous peddlers use to attract our attention.
Whatever it is you're doing can now be faster, simpler, easier, but not better. Well, that last part depends on what we agree better means.
If we believe that the theory of evolution holds any water, then we know that stress leads to adaptation. We also know that convenience lowers stress (or friction or any other tech bro word the peddlers love). If we eliminate stress, we eliminate (or at least lower) adaptation, which means we stunt progress.
Rapid busywork and reduced progress create overwhelm and dissatisfaction. Our propensity to see convenience as progress intensifies the malaise of dread that we're convinced we want to avoid.
Now, of course, safety and other basic needs are essential. There's no need to live under constant threat, but do we really need an idea synthesis machine or the ability to generate endless reams of garble when what we're suffering from is a deficit of meaning and not one of content?
Consider hobbies - and I can only talk about mine, but substitute any of yours - like playing pool, lifting weights, writing, and music. Let's use an example from each.
Pool: Missing shots in a critical match breaks me. It triggers shame, hopelessness, frustration, and confusion, each of which refines the focus of my next practice session. So I practice and miss. I practice and miss. I practice and I sink the ball. I miss the ball in competition, then I pot the ball in competition, and then I struggle to miss the ball. This route takes time and pain.
Lifting: My back rounds at the bottom of a deadlift, so I feel a pinch in my back as I lift the weight. I focus instead on bracing my core, so my butt wink is gone, but now I notice I lose tension in my lats, so my chest drops. Then, I learn every cue that goes into a deadlift - feet, hips, grip, lats, and eyes - and I push the world away. I take a year, but I finally have it - a heavy deadlift with virtually no strain on the back.
Writing: I stare at a blank page. Backspace gets a lot of action. Then I sense what feels like rage, but is just the friction of birthing a sentence from the embryo of a thought. I wrestle, I writhe, I crumble, and I strain every mental sinew to gather myself to put down a sequence of words that isn't bloody stupid. I could get better, sure, and this is a start.
Music: I play one string but hear the creak of another because my little finger has more ambition than my index has strength. It looks so effortless when someone 'gifted' plays, and here I am with no natural ability and even less grit, just a simian moron plucking at strings to ward off existential angst. Weeks go by until one evening...no creak. No symphony either. Just one note. But also, just that one note.
At the end of each of these self-inflicted pain rituals, my mood lifts. I don't know what that means, and I don't know how - but it feels better. It's the effort that feels better. The outcome is just feedback for the next bout of effort.
And then the convenience peddlers come along - use an aiming system to shoot, an LLM to write, an algorithm to generate a tune, and thankfully, nothing yet to lift a weight for you. If satisfaction follows effort and acts as a reasonable orienting principle for a finite lifespan, then what is the proliferation of convenience going to do to it? How will eight hours a day of prompting and meetings and takeout support any of the human indices of wellbeing? What does it do to craft?
A life is a work of art that we're going to make irrespective of our predispositions. If the markets can stay irrational longer than we can remain solvent, then convenience peddlers can remain promotional longer than we can stay sane (or alive). And despite my intense desire to, thanks to worry and gravity, I don't take sanity or staying alive for granted.
Convenience is seductive and useful if intentionally chosen. If we're careless, we're trading the satisfaction of effort for the eventual emptiness of atrophy. This message is not a bid to influence choice, but a reminder that choices have consequences and intention is a critical muscle to exercise in our effort to build a day that doesn't feel like juggling on a treadmill mounted on stilts.



Comments